Goodman Community Center | For Neapolitan pizza, try It’s Good For…

For Neapolitan pizza, try It’s Good For You on the north side

In 2023, It’s Good For You Pizza opened on North Sherman Avenue featuring pizza made in a wood-fired oven.

February 9, 2024 |
Share
It's Good For You Pizza's ordering counter with the wood-fired oven behind it.
The pizzas at It’s Good For You Pizza are made in a wood-fired oven, named The Microwave, that has to be heated 2-3 hours ahead of time. The pizzas bake at a temperature between 900-1,000 degrees Fahrenheit.

By Alesia Mayfield, Eastside News

As a boy growing up in Palermo, Sicily, Alessandro Monachello made pizzas in the wood-fired oven at the family’s country home. When he came to Madison in 2006, he didn’t speak English, but he was able to find employment as a cook. Over the years, Monachello worked at Osteria Papavero, Madison Club and Magnus. As he learned English, saying “It’s good for you” sounded good to him. As his English improved, “It’s good for you” stayed with friends as a joke. And it’s also part of the name of his Madison pizzeria.

It’s Good For You Pizza opened in February 2023, and Monachello operates it with his business partner Christopher Guglielmo. Located at 521 N. Sherman Ave., the pizzeria is modeled after the pizzerias Monachello frequented in Sicily. There are six pizzas on the regular menu. The menu is small by design. That way the pizzeria can focus on quality, Monachello said.

Like the pizzas he made as a boy, the ones at It’s Good For You Pizza are made in a wood-fired oven where the oven has to be heated 2-3 hours ahead of time. The pizzas bake at a temperature between 900-1,000 degrees Fahrenheit. Though the pizzas can be made in a gas oven, Monachello considers that “cheating.”

The style of pizza at It’s Good For You Pizza is Neapolitan, which gets a chewy, bubbly crust from the wood-fire oven. The Margherita, a vegetarian pizza made with basil oil (a combination of basil and olive oil) and di latte mozzarella (made with cow’s milk), is the top seller. Using the six pizzas on the regular menu for inspiration, customers can build their own pizza.

Before Monachello and Guglielmo had their storefront pizzeria, they started their pizza business in 2016 by catering and selling at the Northside Farmers’ Market and at public and private events. Because the business was mobile, it operated from May to October.

Having a stable, physical location allowed for expansion so the partners could operate throughout the year as a takeout with limited dining. There are plans to have patio dining in the summer. The catering continues through the mobile business.

Due to their success at the Northside Farmers’ Market, Monachello and Guglielmo thought it was a natural fit to be on the north side.

“(We are) excited to be part of the process to improve (the business community of the north side),” said Monachello.

It’s Good For You Pizza boasts a loyal following, and Monachello’s three keys to creating a successful business are: good counter service, having a small crew and taking care of the customers.

It’s Good For You Pizza is open Thursdays through Saturdays from 5-8:30 p.m. and accepts orders through Door Dash.

For more information or to view the menu, visit itsgoodforyoumadison.com.

Previous Next
Dean Proctor's front yard with installations featuring historical information.

Lakeland Avenue resident has a trove of info in yard

June 12, 2024

Dean Proctor has created an installation in front of his house offering historical documents that paints a picture of what life used to be like in the neighborhood.

Eastside News Stories, Neighborhood News

Spotlight on two graduating Goodman teens

June 6, 2024

A pair of high schoolers, Madison La Follette’s Kiara Lillie and Madison East’s Lydia Olson, who have been longtime, dedicated participants graduate June 8

Lussier LOFT High School, Eastside News Stories, TEENworks, Teens